AFC in order for starting #1. Peyton Manning #2. Tom Brady #3. David Carr NFC In order for starting #1. Donavann Mcnabb #2. Rex Grossman #3. Marc Bulger How do you guys see it.. I would put rex 1st but Mcnabb has him beat in yards and Tds
I am so shocked that Daunte & Kitna aren't on the aforementined list. LOL. Seriously, what about Carson P & Hasselbeck?
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Bears#1Fan)</div><div class='quotemain'>AFC in order for starting #1. Peyton Manning #2. Tom Brady #3. David Carr NFC In order for starting #1. Donavann Mcnabb #2. Rex Grossman #3. Marc Bulger How do you guys see it.. I would put rex 1st but Mcnabb has him beat in yards and Tds</div> I think it shakes out like this...... 1.Peyton Manning 2.David Carr 3.Tom Brady ........ 1.Donovan McNabb 2.Marc Bulger 3.Eli Manning... I know, where is Grossman?Well, I think if he holds up for one more game then he is in but for now, show me you can keep it going and stay healthy!
AFC 1. Carson Palmer 2. Peyton Manning 3. David Carr NFC 1. Donvan McNabb 2. Rex Grossman 3. Eli Manning
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Bears#1Fan)</div><div class='quotemain'>AFC in order for starting #1. Peyton Manning #2. Tom Brady #3. David Carr NFC In order for starting #1. Donavann Mcnabb #2. Rex Grossman #3. Marc Bulger How do you guys see it.. I would put rex 1st but Mcnabb has him beat in yards and Tds</div> I agree as well. Those would be my picks if the season ended today.
Everyone here does know that more than likely Michael Vick will take one of those NFC QB's places when the real results are in, right? Not saying that he should be there again, but the Pro Bowl is a popularity contest as far as I'm concerned.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (JustBry07)</div><div class='quotemain'>Everyone here does know that more than likely Michael Vick will take one of those NFC QB's places when the real results are in, right? Not saying that he should be there again, but the Pro Bowl is a popularity contest as far as I'm concerned.</div> unfortunatly u are probably right but i'm hoping that it wont be true and people will actually look at the talent of the QBs from the NFC this year here are my picks 1. Peyton Manning 2. Tom Brady 3. Carson Palmer 1. Donovan McNabb 2. Rex Grossman 3. Eli Manning i would put Carr there but Palmer will be the more popular pick because like bry said its a popularity contest and the avg fan doesnt know how good Carr is doing right now
My revised list NFC 1. John Kitna 2. Kurt Warner 3. Mark Brunelle AFC 1. Ben Roethlisberger 2. Aaron Brooks 3. Jake Plummer Sorry felt like doing some ball busting lol
NFC 1. Donovan McNabb 2. Rex Grossman 3. Drew Brees(have we forgotten what's going on in NO?) AFC 1. Peyton Manning 2. Carson Palmer 3. Steve McNair
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (blackadder)</div><div class='quotemain'>I am so shocked that Daunte & Kitna aren't on the aforementined list. LOL. Seriously, what about Carson P & Hasselbeck?</div> hasselbeck has thrown more INT's then TDs 6-7 and carson is off to a rocky start
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Packersfan)</div><div class='quotemain'>NFC - McNabb, Grossman, Bulger AFC - Carr, Manning, Huard (filled in great for Green),</div> Huard will not be the starter when Green gets back though. you can't say that he's having a better year than Brady, Palmer or even Leftwich.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (bakes781)</div><div class='quotemain'>NFC 1. Donovan McNabb 2. Rex Grossman 3. Drew Brees(have we forgotten what's going on in NO?) AFC 1. Peyton Manning 2. Carson Palmer 3. Steve McNair</div> wow great point i forgot about Brees he deserves to be on my list over Eli Manning right now
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (cubuffsman78)</div><div class='quotemain'><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Packersfan)</div><div class='quotemain'>NFC - McNabb, Grossman, Bulger AFC - Carr, Manning, Huard (filled in great for Green),</div> Huard will not be the starter when Green gets back though. you can't say that he's having a better year than Brady, Palmer or even Leftwich.</div> ------------Yds Att Cmp TDs Ints Long Rating Brady - 1031 162 88 8 3 35 82.6 Palmer - 917 120 75 6 4 43 88.8 Leftwich - 1034 155 94 7 5 51 82.0 Huard - 769 104 73 5 0 78 107.4
Interesting to see all the love for David Carr in this thread. Statistically, he is having a great year. But pro bowl QBs always come from a winning team. Anyone know the last time a QB went to the Pro Bowl when his team had a losing record? Has it ever happened? Probably for Michael Vick...
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Pack Attack)</div><div class='quotemain'>Anyone know the last time a QB went to the Pro Bowl when his team had a losing record? Has it ever happened?</div> Seems like Archie Manning made the PB.
Im suprised that John Kitna has throw the 2nd highest amount of yards. The QBs that I think will get hot at the end of the season are, Jake Delhomme- Steve Smith is almost 100% and Keyshawn is doing great. Marc Bulger- With steven jackson leading the league in rushing, Bulger has more time to make great throws Carson Palmer- he isnt doing very well right now, but with TJ and Chad he can do great. The only problem is that o-line is sucking right now Philip Rivers- He beat the good steelers team and is starting to look good. The only problem is his WRs are a little lacking but he makes it up with LT and Gates QBs whose play will go down- Rex Grossman- once the chicago winds start his passing will go down Drew Bledsoe- his play is already detoriating, all you have to do is blitz the hell out of him, and he will make bad throws. He will eventually be beaten out by Tony Romo.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div><div class='quotemain'>Drew Bledsoe- his play is already detoriating, all you have to do is blitz the hell out of him, and he will make bad throws. He will eventually be beaten out by Tony Romo.</div> I still think it's very premature to declare this as if it's inevitable. I mean yeah eventually Drew & QBs of similar type will become extinct, but there's still a place in today's NFL for a rocket armed QB. If you blitz the hell out of Peyton Manning & the protection fails to pick it up you can be sure he's going to struggle just as easily.
