Um...does anyone else feel that the pending trade in the Keeper League is lopsided? Cedric Benson (not a starter) and Sinorice Moss (out injured) for Thomas Jones and Mushin Muhammad? I know it's a keeper league, but this is a completely biased traded as far as this year goes. In my opinion, anyway. Anyone else object?
benson did score 2 yesterday and its is a keeper league. Although slightly lopsided someone is stocking up for the future so Im am not in objection for the trade.
if you looked at my current team, i have almost nobody for the future. that was the sole purpose of the trade.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Pack Attack)</div><div class='quotemain'>Um...does anyone else feel that the pending trade in the Keeper League is lopsided? Cedric Benson (not a starter) and Sinorice Moss (out injured) for Thomas Jones and Mushin Muhammad? I know it's a keeper league, but this is a completely biased traded as far as this year goes. In my opinion, anyway. Anyone else object?</div> IF a NFL GM made the trade, and his team was in last place with 2 older productive players for 2 1st rd draft picks of the last 2 years, how would you rate the trade? Good or bad?
My initial reaction when seeing the trade was that it was lopsided....if it was a non-keeper league, I would definelty be suspisious....but, it is a keeper, and it is 2 young players for 2 established vet starters....I think part of a keeper league is that these types of trade will occur from time to time....clearly one guy looks like hes bailing on the season and the other guy is going for it this year, future be damned....if we were voting, Id vote this is acceptable, but only becuase it is a keeper league, and selling off your older vets for young talent is a viable strategy....
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (BearsFan1)</div><div class='quotemain'>IF a NFL GM made the trade, and his team was in last place with 2 older productive players for 2 1st rd draft picks of the last 2 years, how would you rate the trade? Good or bad?</div> What does that have to do with this? At most, Bobby will be 1 game out of the playoffs after tonight and only one of the players you are giving up was a 1st round draft pick....
My whole thing is, Achilles Last Stand has two kickers, two defenses and Antonio Chatman on his squad. If you look at the waiver wire, there's a ton of young talent out there to build with...at receiver, tight end and running back. But if no one else objects, then I won't either.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (TheBeef)</div><div class='quotemain'><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (BearsFan1)</div><div class='quotemain'>IF a NFL GM made the trade, and his team was in last place with 2 older productive players for 2 1st rd draft picks of the last 2 years, how would you rate the trade? Good or bad?</div> What does that have to do with this? At most, Bobby will be 1 game out of the playoffs after tonight and only one of the players you are giving up was a 1st round draft pick....</div> It isnt nearly as lopsided as it appears, jones will lose carries to benson as season continues. Mushin is definately the reason for the trade, i think he is going to put up bigger and bigger #s as the temperature drops.
