No it isn't. The question was who I thought was the most underrated and your post just confirms to me that I am right about that. I wasn't soliciting people's opinions. I already know them. That's why I said he was underrated.
I'm not underrating him. I'm pointing out that the information you presented as support are factually incorrect. You have presented categories for analysis that are much closer to objective than subjective.
I think Kenyon Martin is a helluva lot better than people and the media give him credit for. Although I give them leeway cause of his injury last year, but man the guy can play.
I think most people take this as who does the majority of fans/media underrate, and ghoti is saying that he personally thinks Elton Brand is underrated. Or something like that.
Yes, saying I would give him the ball if I needed a basket is as objective as it gets. Probably a page on 82games.com for all my theoretical head coaching decisions.
versatility is one thing, it's nice to have really, but putting the ball in the basket it what counts the most, thus Andrew Bogut having more versatile offensive skills than Shaq means diddley squat. Brand is a top notch PF I won't disagree with that, but Duncan and KG are better scorers.. regardless of how they accomplish it. Also Bosh has better range and handle offensively than Brand.
