I guess David Thorpe doesn't read Blazers Edge. If he did, he'd learn pretty quick the posters over there are better informed than he is. http://www.blazersedge.com/2008/10/30/649820/trade-oden-a-comparison-wi
Big guys miss more games. Thats the way it is. No reason to assume Oden equals Sam Bowie. He has a sprained foot.
There is one part of what Thorpe said that deserves serious consideration: would Greg be better off if he took off some of the weight he added during rehab?
He's not a writer. He's the director of the IMG Academy, and his focus is in basketball. IMG is a premier athletic training outfit. Included in it is the Nick Bollettieri Tennis Academy, which pretty much anyone who has ever been good at tennis has attended. Due to his relationship with players and expertise, Thorpe is a frequent guest on ESPN.
50 pounds is too much. As long as he's fast and big and strong, that's good. at 235...I mean that's what some SF's weigh.
He does chats and rookie analysis at ESPN- he's probably the most insightful guy they've got there (but I'm not saying he's not wrong here!)
When someone wants to point out an injury that occurred to Oden that wouldn't have happened to a normal person put in that situation, then I'll buy Thorpe's analysis. ANYONE would have injured their ankle/foot the way his was twisted.