A prolific, high rated passer on a shortened NFL career. Three Superbowl appearances...1 win (so far). Hall of Fame material?
I'm sorry, but this must be said fail On the Kurt Warner note, yeah, HOF, probably not first time though.
lol, not fail at all. Thrlla is right, the only thing to contend that is maybe Manning is below Brady, not Kurt.
Kurt took a big break from real football though, there are a few QBs in the last ten years that have comparable careers. Manning, Brees, Favre, Brady, Donovan. Even Trent Green outplayed Warner on his own team in 2000 (that's a huge reason why Faulk got love that season), and had three straight great seasons. Granted Kurt's career is better, but it isn't clear cut at all he's second best or even top three; and I don't agree one should judge everything on team success. He's simply HOF material and that's all that needs to be said.
This, just because he didn't have the opportunity to play like other guys, so statistically it looks pretty good, but should be better.