Cadillac Williams 23 years old (24 in April) 5'11" 220 290 carries 1,178 yards 4.1 ypc 6 TD Ronnie Brown 24 years old 6'0" 230 207 carries 907 yards 4.4 ypc 4 TD Which would you rather have and why?
I'd take Ronnie Brown and not just becuase I'm a Dolphin fan. For one Brown is a lot more versatile. Cadillac is a one dimensional player. Brown can do it all. He's a better run blocker, pass blocker, and reciever. Also, he's much more durable. You can tell just by his strong build. Cadillac is going to struggle staying healthy, he's a smaller and lighter back. Brown can take a beating and be a real workhorse. People also underestimate Brown's speed, he may not look very fast, but he packs a big burst. And of course, probably his best quality, he's one of the best break tackle backs in the league, which Cadilac certainly isn't. I compare Ronnie to a better version of Ricky Williams, lets just hope he doesn't end up like him.
I'd take Brown too. He has a bigger frame and he can run in the inside too. I see him being like Curtis Martin. Caddy is a menace at running to the outside but Brown is more talented, imo and more versatile.
