Who do you want running your team?? Both play on the same team, but Tinsley has been injured for a good portion of the season. I'll post later.
I think when healthy, AJ can't hold Tinsley's jockstrap. Tins is a top 15 PG in the NBA when healthy, AJ is nothing more than a solid veteran backup. Tinsley's court vision is really great and he can definitely out-quick a lot of guards on the stop-n-go. He can also hit the 3 and really steps up offensively when he's needed (and healthy).
