Eli Manning has to be mentioned, he treated like he's going to be an elite QB and he can't hit 56% of his passes.
Hes just overhyped because hes Peytons brother.I think Mike Vick is overated right now,I think hes going to have a break out season this year because the west coast offense takes time to get used to but hes overated right now.
Michael Vick. As much as I love to watch him play and watch he get out of the pocket and run I would have to say he's overrated. He has quite abit of hype. He hasnt done near as much as he's done to live up to his name. He isnt to much of a good passer. He gets to much endorcements than he should. But then agian all sports players do. Lebron for an example. Vick hasnt carried his team to much like they said he would. Had rough injuries. But like what Heatfan said he could break out
Vick. He could'nt hit a open wide receiver 10 feet away. He sucks cock. He runs the ball and he acts like Walter Peyton jukin and sh*t, and everyone hypes him up to be like the duel threat QB. Then he gets tackled and hes hurt, or he bruised his pinkie or some gay sh*t. Im sick of him, Matt Shaub has better leadership and better skills than Vick. Vick does have the tools to be the best QB ever. Really that is true. But he hasn't even come near his potential. His accuracy sucks, he is a baby on the field.For the past 3 years I've heard he's adjusted to the West Coast offense, thats bull sh*t. He looks worse every year. No reason to believe this year is going to be any different.And you cant even fu*kin understand him when he talks.
Eli Manning. In all reality, he is at most and average quaterback. He gets so much attention because of his amazing brother and father. Like BCB said, he completes like 55% of his passes, mainly because he has a great wide reciver core.Underated would definantely be Carson Palmer.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div><div class='quotemain'>Underated would definantely be Carson Palmer.</div>Yup, definately Palmer as the underrated, I would have said Jimmy Smith too before he retiredOverrated:Michael VickThe Manning BrothersChad Pennington was reallllly overrated, but he's been exposed
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div><div class='quotemain'>Give him 2 more years and he could be as good as Peyton.</div>hopefully he'll be as good in the regular season and the exact opposite of peyton in the playoffs.
I would say Michael Vick and Chad Pennington. Vick because he can't throw a ball worth a sh*t and yet he still made the pro bowl because all those stupid 11 year olds voted for him just because he is fast. He threw as many INT's as TD's. He cant throw on the run worth a sh*t. He throws a pretty ball but it is always way off the reciever. A TE is the only guy the man can throw to because if he doesnt put the ball right onto the Tight End he can still catch it.Chad Pennington because some people act like he is the savior of the NYJ. Come on man. THis guy is a pansy. He is injury prone and he cant throw the ball more than 20 yards lol. He has the weakest arm in the NFL.
Chad Pennington was a very good QB when healthy, but when you have no offensive line bad things happen. He has a weak arm but he was very accurate and a good leader.
Oh come on. I dont care about his line. Sure he is accurate and all but when it's 3rd and 20 what is he going to do? He can only throw a decent ball 10-15 yards.
I think Kerry Collins is one of the most overrated QBs, at a time I would have considered him a top 5 QB but in the last 3-4 years hes really fallen behind. He cant even do well with 2 amazing recievers in Porter and Moss. As for Michael Vick hes overrated as a passer but he is not overrated as a QB, sure he cant throw great but then again who does he have to throw to? Roddy White? Their entire team is Vick and Dunn, its amazing that they can stay above .500 and even be a playoff contender..Underratedrew BreesCarson Palmer
Chad Pennington. Hes got a f*cking pussy arm, and he's always hurt anyways. Mike Vick. More of a running back than a quarterback.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (BCB @ May 17 2006, 03:35 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>Eli Manning has to be mentioned, he treated like he's going to be an elite QB and he can't hit 56% of his passes.</div>Shut up dude, are you crazy? He's not even close to being treated as an elite QB. He's a rising star, but he has along way to go.And as for the elite receiving core...whos elite? Plaxico Burress is a borderline #1 receiver, Toomer is on the downside of his career and Shockey, well he's Shockey but he can only do so much.I mean Burress and Toomer is nothing special man..Your all being stupid now the kid had very dominant games and he had a bad playoff game that wasn't his fault. It makes no sense the kid is in his 3rd year now he's not overrated he's not even considered great..!!!As for most overrated I would say Brett Favre for the simple fact he throws way too many INTs and is not even a top 10 QB IMO with too many INTS and then Mike Vick because he makes Pro Bowls and he throws stats like 12 td, 12 int...that's just sad.<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (kingjamez @ May 17 2006, 04:51 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>Vick. He could'nt hit a open wide receiver 10 feet away. He sucks cock. He runs the ball and he acts like Walter Peyton jukin and sh*t, and everyone hypes him up to be like the duel threat QB. Then he gets tackled and hes hurt, or he bruised his pinkie or some gay sh*t. Im sick of him, Matt Shaub has better leadership and better skills than Vick. Vick does have the tools to be the best QB ever. Really that is true. But he hasn't even come near his potential. His accuracy sucks, he is a baby on the field.For the past 3 years I've heard he's adjusted to the West Coast offense, thats bull sh*t. He looks worse every year. No reason to believe this year is going to be any different.And you cant even fu*kin understand him when he talks.</div>Hater? Wow dude. Schaub is no where near Vick.Schaub had a good game against a NE secondary with 5 injured players including Rodney Harrison and their top 2 CBs and Tedy Bruschi I believe was just returning.He has not done well against any respectable defense.
Schaub can throw the ball really well. The only reason that he isnt starting right now is that Vick is quick and he can win games with his quickness and athleticism. (a.k.a. running with the ball)
Clearly Vick. He can run, oh my god! So can RB's and WR's. It's not that hard. He can't win for isht.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Bleeding Green @ May 17 2006, 07:51 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>Clearly Vick. He can run, oh my god! So can RB's and WR's. It's not that hard. He can't win for isht.</div>Ok so Vick doesnt win games.....Soooo where do they get their wins from? They are a good team and Vick does win games, hate him if you want but thats what he does best, he does whatever it takes to win.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Bleeding Green @ May 17 2006, 08:51 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>Clearly Vick. He can run, oh my god! So can RB's and WR's. It's not that hard. He can't win for isht.</div>He has been in the playoffs ever since his 2nd yr. in the NFL with a team that is horrid on defense besides 3 players(Kerney,Hall,Brooking) and has not one #2 WR on his team! His wideouts are full of 3-4 spot WR's<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Madness @ May 18 2006, 05:50 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>Mike Vick.. If he couldn't scramble like that he'd be backup</div>Yah but he can run so shut the F*ck up lol....! Thats like saying if Yao was 7'5 he would be a back up! lolBut anywayz i think Daunte Coulpepper is overrated...! Look what he did without Moss this year....! He was horrible! Its easy to be an outstanding QB when you can throw it up and have a guy like moss go get it, and when he didnt have anyone to do that he sucked balls! Although i think this year he will put miami in the playoffs because he has an explosive WR in Chris Chambers
