Well, if I had to choose, I would say Foye. He is the better offensive player, and offense is all McCants has. Foye has a much higher ceiling, and the ability to play 2 positions. He's more athletic and he also works hard. McCants has had work ethic questions in the past, and he also might be out for this entire season, or most of it. But at the same time - Foye hasn't even played a game yet.
Foye easily. He will be a much better NBA player. Rashad will be a good scorer, but he just won't be as good as Foye. Foye is quick, electric, a good shooter, he can take it in, and he is just an all-around phenomanal scorer. His defense is decent too. If I had to, I would comoare him as a cross between Chauncey Billups, and Gilbert Arenas.
I am gonna agree with you all and say Foye. You think McHale is now kicking himself for not taking say Danny Granger or Hakim Warrick. You can't really play that game though, still just something to think about.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (CelticBalla32 @ Sep 4 2006, 08:47 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>Well, if I had to choose, I would say Foye. He is the better offensive player, and offense is all McCants has. Foye has a much higher ceiling, and the ability to play 2 positions. He's more athletic and he also works hard. McCants has had work ethic questions in the past, and he also might be out for this entire season, or most of it..</div> I think youv'e summed it up perfectly! Foye for me too.
I personally think they'll average around the same stats but Rashad McCants will be the overall better player. Foye is a combo guard and can't run the point and is undersized to run the shooting guard position. He doesn't do anything over the top and he's just solid at everything he does. However, McCants has better athleticism,a better shot, and can get to the hole much better than Foye. The surgery won't effect McCants much and he'll still be a great player in this league. Foye will have to eventually learn and adjust to the point guard position because in the future, you will see the backcourt of Foye and McCants and McCants won't be playing the point and Foye will.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (RashadzMcCantz @ Sep 5 2006, 06:41 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>I personally think they'll average around the same stats but Rashad McCants will be the overall better player. Foye is a combo guard and can't run the point and is undersized to run the shooting guard position. He doesn't do anything over the top and he's just solid at everything he does. However, McCants has better athleticism,a better shot, and can get to the hole much better than Foye. The surgery won't effect McCants much and he'll still be a great player in this league. Foye will have to eventually learn and adjust to the point guard position because in the future, you will see the backcourt of Foye and McCants and McCants won't be playing the point and Foye will.</div>You don't have to be great at running an offense to be a good pg. Loook at Gilbert Arenas. What do you mean, he will just be solid? Randy is as explosive as anything, a great shooter, and a great defensive player as well. He will put alot of points on the board, and play great D. McCants can't get to the whole much better than Foye. That is plain rediculous, man.Obviously you havnt seen much of Randy Foye.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (CB4AllStar @ Sep 5 2006, 05:01 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>You don't have to be great at running an offense to be a good pg. Loook at Gilbert Arenas. What do you mean, he will just be solid? Randy is as explosive as anything, a great shooter, and a great defensive player as well. He will put alot of points on the board, and play great D. McCants can't get to the whole much better than Foye. That is plain rediculous, man.Obviously you havnt seen much of Randy Foye.</div>Of course I haven't seen much of Foye,lol. I've seen and met Foye a couple times but he isn't as explosive as McCants is and Foye isn't nearly as great of a shooter as Arenas is. Arenas is a great shooter and can get to the free throw line better than anyone in the league. Foye is going to be a great player and possibly an all-star but he won't be a superstar in this league.
Dude, Foye is alot more explosive than McCants. I feel that McCants relies on shooting too often, at times. Thats why I made the comparison. Foye can shoot, and he is a great penetrator. He is a better defensive player than McCants, and I bet you anything that he will also end up scoring more than Rashad in the L.
Dude, one line posts are not aloud in the comparison forum. Let alone one word posts. Explain why you think so. That was 98% spam.
foye, because he takes on more leadership. he is more athletic than mccants and foye has other factors to help him when his shooting is off.sry.
