XBOX. I have one, but I'm not being bias. I hear PS2 has more games, but the only ones I really care about anyway are the major sport ones, like Madden, Live, etc. Also, XBOX has Halo and PS2 doesn't. The main thing that puts XBOX over the top though is it's graphics. They're much better than PS2's.
I like the PS2's games a lot, but the original Xbox had those cool small things that made it really good (graphics, hard drive, etc.)Xbox.
Yeah I agree with all your points only thing I dont like about Xbox is that the controller or the console breaks here and there and dont like the feel of the controllor.
Xbox... and the 360 is better than whatever the PS3 will have to offer. Sony will take a HUGE hit if Microsoft goes ahead with it's plan to release Halo 3 at the same time Sony releases PS3.