wats so horrendous about the cutting...the bg is alittle plain though. grey is a dull color so I would work on that.
Its alrite, the render coudl be blende in with the BG a little more. The Bg is also a little dull. Overal ok sig. 7/10
Its an ok sig, background could be not so dull.. I think you should desaturate the logo, do some blending on the main render
I haven't had photoshop that long so im tryin to get better but its goin to take me some time to get really good.