DYC Sig Comp: Votes Round 2

Discussion in 'Graphics Showcase' started by Oranje, Jun 2, 2007.

  1. Oranje

    Oranje DYC *********

    you guys know wat to do[​IMG]

    the theme for round 2 was:

    The world game

    basically, take a memorable moment (doesnt have to be a goal, players celebrating after the final whistle maybe? or fans celebrating with a player?) from the two previous world cups (german and korea-japan) and make a sig from it.

    round 2 was between wolf and echo.

    wolf's sig:

    http://i138.photobucket.com/albums/q250/Carbon2k7/Zidane--goal2.png">

    echo
    [​IMG]

    please vote for the sig that works best with the theme and overall appearance. also, state who you voted for and why. thats why theres no poll

    voting closes tuesday 9pm AEST
     
  2. Lennon 18

    Lennon 18 DYC Key Squad player

    Wolf Sig:
    Love the render effect and also the daubs of Zidane around but if you lower the opacity of them then it would even better.. Text is nice and shiny and goes with the Border which is also nice with the shiny effect

    Echo Sig:
    Look like you have just got pictures put them on the canvas and added some brushing lower the opacity and used colour balance... also think naming the team was the wrong choice

    My vote:
    Wolf
     
  3. bbwMax

    bbwMax Member

    Wolf i like the bits of Zidane around the place and the sort of ripple water effect.

    Echo i like the Name bar and the colours but a bit too plain IMO

    My vote:Wolf
     
  4. Hudge

    Hudge Active Member

    I vote wolf because I like the ripples and everything. Plus it was a true great (Zidane)'s last World Cup
     
  5. Oranje

    Oranje DYC *********

    please vote for the sig which (firstly) symbolises the theme. second criteria is effects, textures etc. dont vote for a sig purely jus on looks.
     
  6. The 12th Man

    The 12th Man DYC Im Cantona i go as i want

    Wolf - I dont really like the watery/liquify effect on the sig. I just dont like the look of it. But the rest looks pretty good.

    Echo - I like the way u put the team names in there but the effect is really boring. As wat beggsy sed it looks like u have just brushed over the sig and put the layer on a low opacity. Yours follows the theme though.

    Vote - Wolf
     
  7. twofivefive

    twofivefive DYC Boro for FA Cup 2008.

    I'm voting for Echo, reasons below.

    Wolf - I don't really like the effects on yours, it's a bit messy and IMO it doesn't properly capture the memorable moment, it could just be a picture of Zidane kicking a ball. And also the colours are all over the place, it seems too contrasted.

    Echo - I like the way all the theme goes through the whole sig and how they blend into each other really well. The bar with the names is at a good spot and looks good. This sig captures the moment more than Wolf's and since that is what we're meant to be voting on, my vote goes to you.
     
  8. Wolf

    Wolf Sig and Avatar made by me

    <div class="quote_poster">twofivefive Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">

    it could just be a picture of Zidane kicking a ball.
    </div>

    I was waiting for someone to say that, its actually Zidane scoring that Penalty which hit the crossbar and just bounced in.
     
  9. Flight643

    Flight643 DYC *********

    We dont know that Wolf, that could be any picture, next time make it more clearer to avoid confusion.

    Now I do think Wolfs is better, but sticking to the theme then I would have to vote for Echo because his sig showing the actual theme.
     
  10. Oranje

    Oranje DYC *********

    <div class="quote_poster">Flight643 Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">We dont know that Wolf, that could be any picture, next time make it more clearer to avoid confusion.

    Now I do think Wolfs is better, but sticking to the theme then I would have to vote for Echo because his sig showing the actual theme.</div>

    so ur vote is to echo?
     
  11. Flight643

    Flight643 DYC *********

    Yes my vote is echo
     
  12. echo369

    echo369 DYC Squad rotation player

    im not saying this coz im losing or anything, but ive noticed that people vote for looks over theme.. i was expecting to lose this one (ask glenn i told him id lose lol) but people have to look at who captures the theme
     
  13. Flight643

    Flight643 DYC *********

    Thats the problem with competitions, alot of people tend to overlook the theme.
     
  14. echo369

    echo369 DYC Squad rotation player

    next round im hoping to see everyne voting for the THEME as the first priority for their vote..
     
  15. Oranje

    Oranje DYC *********

    Voting for round 2 is closed.

    the score was echo 2 - 4 wolf

    so at the end of round 2, the standings are:

    everyones played once, with:

    1. 12thman
    =1. wolf
    2. echo
    =2. twofivefive
     
  16. echo369

    echo369 DYC Squad rotation player

    WOOO!!! 3rd lol.. too good for you glenn
     
  17. twofivefive

    twofivefive DYC Boro for FA Cup 2008.

    We're equal 2nd lol cos we've both lost our only match.
     
  18. Oranje

    Oranje DYC *********

    lol u guys are hilarious

    im sorry to burst ur bubble echo but it was purely alphabetical
     
  19. twofivefive

    twofivefive DYC Boro for FA Cup 2008.

    You'd think I'd be sick of him after knowing him for the 14 years of his life [​IMG]

    (don't tell him but I am SHH lol jk)
     
  20. The 12th Man

    The 12th Man DYC Im Cantona i go as i want

Share This Page