QB numbers

A while back I posted a list of career stats for anonymous QBs and asked the question: Do they belong in the Hall of Fame??.I have decided to do that again but with a more detailed list?.Below are the career numbers of 20 passers?.notice there are no names attached to the list?..they are sorted by yards passing?.I don?t want anyone to add the names or mention who any of these guys are if you know?.What I would like to do is have you guys go through the list and simply state Yes or No as to whether the numbers are Hall of Fame worthy?..feel free to add any comments too??In a week or so I will add the names to the list and tally the results?then I will post 20 more.....I have compiled the same type of list for RBs and WRs too, which I will post separately after we are done with the QBs?.






Comp. Att. Yards TD INT Comp % Yds/Att Int % TD %
1.3105 5311 38147 261 199 58.46% 7.18 3.75% 4.91%

2.2969 5205 37920 247 184 57.04% 7.29 3.54% 4.75%

3.3193 5599 36876 201 165 57 .03% 6.59 2.95% 3.59%

4.2874 4779 35467 237 175 60.14% 7.42 3.66% 4.96%

5.2841 4923 34837 203 175 57.71% 7.08 3.55% 4.12%

6.2593 5076 34665 209 247 51.08% 6.83 4.87% 4.12%

7.2874 5024 34241 196 204 57.21% 6.82 4.06% 3.90%

8.2363 4687 33503 244 268 50.42% 7.15 5.72% 5.21%

9.2576 4647 33462 199 157 55.43% 7.20 3.38% 4.28%

10.2667 4149 33124 232 107 64.28% 7.98 2.58% 5.59%

11.2898 4715 32942 165 141 61.46% 6.99 2.99% 3.50%

12.2654 4475 32838 197 160 59.31% 7.34 3.58% 4.40%

13.2433 4262 32224 255 189 57.09% 7.56 4.43% 5.98%

14.2469 4491 31548 214 224 54.98% 7.02 4.99% 4.77%

15.2276 4353 30797 196 257 52.29% 7.07 5.90% 4.50%

16.2429 4289 29979 207 134 56.63% 6.99 3.12% 4.83%

17.2369 4519 29817 196 209 52.42% 6.60 4.62% 4.34%

18.2366 4498 29444 201 194 52.60% 6.55 4.31% 4.47%

19.2136 3741 28711 239 183 57.10% 7.67 4.89% 6.39%

20.2118 3817 28339 212 221 55.49% 7.42 5.79% 5.55%

 

Ill take a shot at it

1.Yes
2.Yes
3.Yes
4.Yes
5.Yes
6.No
7.No
8.No
9.Yes
10.Yes
11.No
12.Yes
13.Yes
14.No
15.No
16.Yes
17.No
18.Yes
19.Yes
20.No

 

This is tough, because I do like to look at things other than stats. What kind of offense they ran, how they performed, etc. Its also tough to look at the numbers without trying to match them up to a name based on knowledge.

The easiest way for me to do this is to break each down to a one game performance and ask if the applicable stats for one game (say 30 attempts for each player) is acceptable to me for a coach.

1. Yes
2. Yes
3. Marginal - would need to see more info
4. Yes
5. Marginal - would need to see more info

6. No
7. No
8. No
9. Yes
10. Yes

11. Yes
12. Yes
13. Yes
14. No
15. No

16. Yes
17. No
18. Marginal - would need to see more info
19. Yes
20. Marginal - would need to see more info

Of course, when I look at this list, I can't help compare each one to the rest on the list. Individually, they may all have merit based on other considerations. But since I know this blind voting is part of the fun, I'm happy to play along.

 

sounds fun

1.Yes
2.Yes
3.Yes
4.Yes
5.Yes
6.No
7.yes
8.No
9.Yes
10.Yes
11.No
12.Yes
13.no
14.No
15.yes
16.Yes
17.No
18.Yes
19.Yes
20.yes

 

I know who all those qb's are now, so i will abstain

 

1.yes
2.yes
3.yes
4.yes
5.yes
6.no
7.no
8.np
9.yes
10.yes
11.no
12.yes
13.yes
14.no
15.no
16.yes
17.no
18.yes
19.yes
20.no

 

will you post who the players are soon, or do we have to wait longer?

 

a few days....I want to get a little more participation if possible...

 

1 yes
2 yes
3 yes
4 yes
5 yes
6 no
7 no
8 no
9 yes
10 no
11yes
12yes
13no
14 no
15 no
16 yes
17 no
18 no
19 yes
20 no

I think that super BOWLS MATTER ALOT!!!!!!!!

 

we all do, but if I put the number of super bowls on the list it will really obvious who some of the guys are

 

I agree with TB if he put SBs up everyone would know exactly who they were

 

I will be posting the results tommorow morning, so if anyone else wants to participate, please do so between now and then....after which I will put up the 1st set of RBs

 

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (TheBeef)</div><div class='quotemain'>

Comp. Att. Yards TD INT Comp % Yds/Att Int % TD %
1.3105 5311 38147 261 199 58.46% 7.18 3.75% 4.91%

2.2969 5205 37920 247 184 57.04% 7.29 3.54% 4.75%

3.3193 5599 36876 201 165 57 .03% 6.59 2.95% 3.59%

4.2874 4779 35467 237 175 60.14% 7.42 3.66% 4.96%

5.2841 4923 34837 203 175 57.71% 7.08 3.55% 4.12%

6.2593 5076 34665 209 247 51.08% 6.83 4.87% 4.12%

7.2874 5024 34241 196 204 57.21% 6.82 4.06% 3.90%

8.2363 4687 33503 244 268 50.42% 7.15 5.72% 5.21%

9.2576 4647 33462 199 157 55.43% 7.20 3.38% 4.28%

10.2667 4149 33124 232 107 64.28% 7.98 2.58% 5.59%

11.2898 4715 32942 165 141 61.46% 6.99 2.99% 3.50%

12.2654 4475 32838 197 160 59.31% 7.34 3.58% 4.40%

13.2433 4262 32224 255 189 57.09% 7.56 4.43% 5.98%

14.2469 4491 31548 214 224 54.98% 7.02 4.99% 4.77%

15.2276 4353 30797 196 257 52.29% 7.07 5.90% 4.50%

16.2429 4289 29979 207 134 56.63% 6.99 3.12% 4.83%

17.2369 4519 29817 196 209 52.42% 6.60 4.62% 4.34%

18.2366 4498 29444 201 194 52.60% 6.55 4.31% 4.47%

19.2136 3741 28711 239 183 57.10% 7.67 4.89% 6.39%

20.2118 3817 28339 212 221 55.49% 7.42 5.79% 5.55%</div>

here are the results....

1.Unanimous HOFer...Dave Krieg 0 titles
2.Unanimous HOFer...Boomer Esiaison 0 titles
3.80% HOFer...Drew Bledsoe 0 titles
4.Unanimous HOFer...Jim Kelly 0 titles
5.80% HOFer...Jim Everett 0 titles
6.Unanimous NOs...Jim Hart 0 titles
7.20% HOFer...Steve Deberg 0 titles
8.Unanimous NOs...John Hadl 0 titles
9.Unanimous HOFer...Phil Simms 1 title
10.80% HOFer...Steve Young 1 title
11.40% HOFer...Troy Aikman 3 titles
12.Unanimous HOFer...Ken Anderson 0 titles
13.80% HOFer...Sonny Jurgenson 0 titles
14.Unanimous NOs...John Brodie 0 titles
15.20% HOFer...Norm Snead 0 titles
16.Unanimous HOFer...Randall Cunningham 0 titles
17.Unanimous NOs...Joe Ferguson 0 titles
18.60% HOFer...Roman Gabriel 0 titles
19.Unanimous HOFer...Len Dawson 3 titles
20.20% HOFer...Y.A. Tittle 0 titles

in order to get credit for a title, the player had to start the game at QB or throw the majority of his teams passes...

 

WOW Aikman only gets 40% thats nuts. Good Post beef. Very Intresting. I may try the RB one.

 

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Pats37)</div><div class='quotemain'>WOW Aikman only gets 40% thats nuts. Good Post beef. Very Intresting. I may try the RB one.</div>

Goes to show you that scheme goes a long way to your success. I think Aikman was a very good quarterback and was in the right scheme. However, if I had to build a team based on a run-and-shoot offense, Aikman would not be close to the guy to call.

Its a fun game, but you have to take the titles into account as well as the team they played on. You would also have to look at people like Jim Hart and Archie Manning and wonder if they were the greatest QBs ever (lol) to put up the stats they did considering the teams they played on.

 

Aikman was awesome and his accuracy was second to none.