Bledsoe ---- no Brady ---- forget the rings, no Pennington ---- close, but no cigars Fiedler --- not in a million years Boller ---- unspectacular, but he s no Leftwich Palmer ----- looking more and more like a bust Rostlisberger -----he s a good one, but Leftwich gets the nod Garcia ---- always has been respectable, but no McNair ---- dare I say no? NO! Carr ----tie Manning ------yes Collins ------next Plummer ----- better than Joke the Mistake Plummer Brees ---- no Green ---- no McNabb ---- no Warner ---- no Brunell ----- no Testaverde ---- no Grossman ---- no Culpepper ---- no Favre ---- pass Harrington ---- no Vick ------ overrated, so no Johnson ---- no Brooks ----- no Delhommme ----a good one, but no Rattay ----no Bulger ----- no Hasselbeck ---- close, but I ll take Byron over Matt McCown ----no So the you have it, only Manning is better than Leftwich right now.
Bledsoe ---- no Brady ---- Yes Pennington ---- close, but no cigars Fiedler --- not in a million years Boller ---- unspectacular, but he s no Leftwich Palmer ----- not looking like bust Rostlisberger ----- just as good, maybe better Garcia ---- always has been respectable, but no McNair ---- He is better, way better. Carr ----Better than leftwich Manning ------yes Collins ------next Plummer ----- Still better than lefty Brees ----playing better than leftwich Green ---- inconsistent but close McNabb ---- definately better Warner ---- no Brunell ----- no Testaverde ---- no Grossman ---- no Culpepper ---- actually a resounding yes Favre ---- Still is better Harrington ---- no Vick ------ overrated, so no Johnson ---- no Brooks ----- definately better Delhommme ----no Rattay ----no Bulger ----- no Hasselbeck ---- he is better McCown ----no
Bledsoe ---- no Brady ---- no Pennington ---- no Fiedler --- no Boller ---- no Palmer -----no Rostlisberger -----yes Garcia ---- no McNair ---- yes... when hes healthy Carr ----yes Manning ------yes Collins ------no Plummer ----- no Brees ---- ... Green ---- no McNabb ---- yes Warner ---- ...this depends Brunell ----- no Testaverde ---- no Grossman ---- no Culpepper ---- yes Favre ---- yes Harrington ---- ... Vick ------ hell no Johnson ---- no Brooks ----- no Delhommme ----no Rattay ----no Bulger ----- no Hasselbeck ---- tie McCown ----no wow, we really disagree
Bledsoe ---- no Brady ---- Yes Pennington ---- yes Fiedler --- not in a million years Boller ---- not yet Palmer ----- no Rostlisberger ----- just as good, maybe better Garcia ---- always has been respectable, but no McNair ---- way better. Carr ----yes Manning ------yes Collins ------next Plummer ----- yes Brees ----as of now Green ---- could be McNabb ---- better Warner ---- yes Brunell ----- no Testaverde ---- no Grossman ---- no Culpepper ---- hell yes Favre ---- yes Harrington ---- no Vick ------ yes Johnson ---- no Brooks ----- some times Delhommme ----no Rattay ----no Bulger ----- yes Hasselbeck ---- yes McCown ----no
If you think leftwich is better than aaron brooks, go look at aaron brooks numbers, it is not even close.
Bledsoe ---- no Brady ---- Yes Pennington ---- Yes Fiedler --- no Boller ---- no Palmer -----no Rostlisberger -----yes Garcia ---- no McNair ---- yes... when hes healthy Carr ----yes Manning ------yes Collins ------no Plummer ----- no Brees ---- Yes Green ---- Yes McNabb ---- yes Warner ---- Yes Brunell ----- no Testaverde ---- no Grossman ---- no Culpepper ---- yes Favre ---- yes Harrington ---- no Vick ------ no Johnson ---- no Brooks ----- yes Delhommme ----no Rattay ----no Bulger ----- no Hasselbeck ---- yes McCown ----no
Bledsoe ---- NO (has the lost that edge to be an NFL QB) Brady ---- YES (It is an insult to Brady to be compared to Byron) Pennington ---- YES (Chad is just better right now at this point) Fiedler ---- NO (No explanation needed) Boller ---- NO (Jury still out) Palmer ---- EVEN (Bryon will eat Palmer's dust in the near future) Rostlisberger ---- YES (Big Ben is the real deal) Garcia ---- NO (Jeff is gutsy, but not better) McNair ---- YES (McNair has to get and stay healthy) Carr ---- YES (Carr will prove it as season goes on) Manning ---- YES (Please, no contest) Collins ---- NO (Too inconsistent) Plummer ---- EVEN (If Plummer stops his mistakes, look out) Brees ---- NO (Brees had his chance and he blew it) Green ---- EVEN (With the years Green has, Green shpuld be better) McNabb ---- YES (Botton line McNabb is better) Warner ---- EVEN (Few years ago, it be an insult to Warner for being compared) Brunell ---- NO (Brunell is done and should retire) Testaverde ---- EVEN (The old man still has tricks up his sleeves) Grossman ---- NO (Could have been better, but got hurt) Culpepper ---- YES (Culpepper on top of his game this year) Favre ---- YES (No way in hell, even if Favre has lost some of his mojo) Harrington ---- YES (This PAC-10 kid can play with the big boys) Vick ---- NO (Overrated, enough said) Johnson ---- NO (Plain and simple, Byron is just better) Brooks ----- YES (Brooks is stuck with a sorry excuse of a team) Delhommme ---- YES (Really watch Jake play and you'll agree he is better) Rattay ---- NO (Some day Rattay could be something special) Bulger ----- YES (Mark has everything you want in a NFL QB) Hasselbeck ---- EVEN (Needs to keep his mouth shut for the overtime coin toss) McCown ---- EVEN (Give him another year with Coach Green and he could be solid)
Wow i cant believe that TD, bulger, Mccown, Testeverde, and Harrington, Delhomme on level or better than Leftwich. Harrington is playing better and does not turn it over so i can give that to you. Delhomme has lost all his weapons and would probably be doing better with them, but cant say he is better based on what if. Mccown is not as good, and never will be because he does not have arm strength. Testeverde is a ver but age thing probably biased me. Bulger throws more picks than anyone despite having the best weapons, he is overrated.
Yeah, I wasn't too sure on Bulger and McCown myself. My first thought was to have McCown EVEN and Bulger NO, but I just went with my second thoughts. I agree with you BF1 on Bulgers INT's, but I like to see McCown run this offense again next year with healthy teammates.
well ya gotta figure... brees is showing us he can play this year, so he may be better, harrington is the same way, nd so are the other people who are like in there 3rd-4th year, cause still around that time, they are still settlin in.... so you wouldnt know whos solid. usually after about 4-5 years of experieence, youll know whos solid and whos not. usually
Bledsoe ---- no Brady ---- Yes Pennington ---- Yes Fiedler --- no Boller ---- no Palmer ----- no Rostlisberger -----Yes Garcia ---- no McNair ---- yes Carr ----yes Manning ------yes Collins ------no Plummer ----- no Brees ---- no Green ---- no McNabb ---- Yes Warner ---- Yes Brunell ----- no Testaverde ---- no Grossman ---- no Culpepper ---- Yes Favre ---- no Harrington ---- no Vick ------ no Johnson ---- no Brooks ----- Yes Delhommme ----no Rattay ----no Bulger ----- no Hasselbeck ---- Yes McCown ----no there you have it, 11 NFL QBs better than Leftwhich, which is pretty good considering hes in his 2nd season....the way it shakes out though, hes the worst starter in his own division....
But I like the sauce, especially that Heinz 57....mmmmm, good.....Im not saying that Leftwich is as good as Favre was, or even that he will be as productive as Favre was in his prime, but at this point, with his arm strength beginging to break down, Favre is likely to go downhill quickly....QBs that rely on arm strength(Marino for instance), dominate when they have it, but lose it quickly when they get older and I see that decline happening to Favre already....I asked myself which of the 2 QBs I would want if I was a coach and only had 6 months to live, and Leftwich won that battle with Favre....
Bledsoe ---- no Brady ---- Yes Pennington ---- Yes Fiedler --- no Boller ---- no Palmer ----- no Rostlisberger -----Yes Garcia ---- no McNair ---- not right now but when he isnt injured yes Carr ---- getting there Manning ------yes Collins ------no Plummer ----- no Brees ---- no Green ---- no McNabb ---- Yes Warner ---- no Brunell ----- no Testaverde ---- no Grossman ---- no Culpepper ---- Yes Favre ---- Yes Harrington ---- no Vick ------ no Johnson ---- no Brooks ----- no Delhommme ----no Rattay ----no Bulger ----- no Hasselbeck ---- Yes McCown ----no i'd put leftwich in the Top 10 cadallac are you serious culpepper is worse than Leftwich thats the stupidest thing i've even heard in a while, too much confidence in him hes on his way though to becoming one of the best in the league
I'm amazed and impressed that most people picked Roethlisberger over Leftwich. Is he that good after only 4 games as a starter? The guy is 22.... blows my mind.
he is that good IMO these are top 5 this year(no order) culpepper mcnabb warner roethlisberger Carr/Leftwich
Bledsoe ---- no Brady ---- Yes Pennington ---- Yes Fiedler --- no Boller ---- no Palmer -----no Rostlisberger -----yes Garcia ---- no McNair ---- no Carr ----yes Manning ------yes Collins ------no Plummer ----- no Brees ---- No Green ---- No McNabb ---- yes Warner ---- Yes Brunell ----- no Testaverde ---- no Grossman ---- no Culpepper ---- yes Favre ---- yes Harrington ---- no Vick ------ Yes ( MUCH MORE UPSIDE) Johnson ---- no Brooks ----- yes Delhommme ----no Rattay ----no Bulger ----- no Hasselbeck ---- yes McCown ----no
