I would say that Tom Brady deserves a lot more credit then he gets. That game on Sunday, just showed what a great QB he is, and is going to be for a long time.
I cant believe you guys. You can make a case for brady on Championships. The other 2 dont belong in same sentence as manning. The are not in his class, this is stupid to argue it in 10 different threads MANNING IS BETTER, no comparison, others dont stack up.
They belong exactly where they were put in the same sentence as Manning. Cause he's doing really well right now means no one else is good according to you pretty much, everytime someone has the opinion someone else is good you jump on it, as if Manning is just GOD. Its getting old all this about Manning, I dont care if hes doing better right now, that doesnt mean the rest of the QBs in the league are just shit now all of a sudden, they are still solid QBs in that list up there. Get over it.
Actually, "Big Ben" would be a fine addition to the list! He is seven or eight years younger than Manning, after all...
He hasn't done enough to be considered one of the greats, but he does have lots of potential. I'm just not sure he'll break a lot of records in Pittsburgh under Cowher. Bill just doesn't have that kind of offense. He believes in running the ball and playing good defense. And he would never "pass first" inside the 5.
Well I like QB's who win championships and I'm a Pats fan, so I think I gotta go with Manning for the regular season.
I'm not sold yet on Manning's psyche for big games. No one is going to argue that he is smart and talented, but how does he do when it really counts? The few games that have really mattered have been pretty terrible for him. I would have to say that I prefer having Manning or Brady, although I am happy with Culpepper...how's that?
on that list, i would b4 this season said manning. but now that i see him i see he is an excelent QB but he would need his recievers....i want to see how manning does next year... now id prolly go with brady. because he just seems more like a team player, and not to go on the selfish thing again with manning. but brady seems more like a leader. all those QBs are great. and you cant go wrong with any of them. so i dont have an answer
I hope he tears his ACL this week Anyway, I pick McNabb (this should get some bitching). He brings his game in the clutch, in case you've all forgotten 4th and 26. Plus I like his scrambling ability over the others. Manning is a close 2nd, the only drawback is I'm not sure how he is in the clutch
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div><div class='quotemain'>I hope he tears his ACL this week</div> Yes, I hope McNabb and T.O. tear their ACLs this week, too. (Okay, so I would never wish injury on anyone, but I had to respond...)
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Pack Attack)</div><div class='quotemain'><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div><div class='quotemain'>I hope he tears his ACL this week</div> Yes, I hope McNabb and T.O. tear their ACLs this week, too. (Okay, so I would never wish injury on anyone, but I had to respond...)</div> lol yall are too funny.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (BrianWestbrook)</div><div class='quotemain'> Anyway, I pick McNabb (this should get some bitching). He brings his game in the clutch</div> NOTE: Clutch does not mean NFC title game. <div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (BrianWestbrook)</div><div class='quotemain'> in case you've all forgotten 4th and 26. Plus I like his scrambling ability over the others.</div> NOTE: Reminding you about one big play he had in playoffs, in case you only remember constant NFC title game loses <div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (BrianWestbrook)</div><div class='quotemain'> Manning is a close 2nd, the only drawback is I'm not sure how he is in the clutch</div> NOTE: Choses a QB in a clutch than specifically avoids comparing him to a player he knows anything about and hates. So to make patriots fans happy i will compare him to Brady. Mcnabb record in NFC title games/Super Bowls 0-3 Brady 3-0. I think it is obvious who anyone would take.
