Can't say I'm feeling this one Tim. Nothing there exemplifies him being a warrior, the BG, nor the picture. The BG is a bit dull, did you colorize it? I would suggest extending the BG throughout both sides, and placing the picture in the middle as is, but doing something to the picture to bring it out. Also, a different font could suit this way better. 6/10.
This definitely isn't the best of your abilities. Very plain. and like Sasha said, nothing that shows he's a Warrior. Maybe have him showing emotion or jumping over someone would suit the wall's theme better. and yes, the font could use some work. 6.5/10
This is a great graphic, I love the background, and the text. This is a verygood graphic. I rate it a 8.5/10.
2nd version is a little too complex for me. i like the text tho, idk why but garnett looks weird IMO. 8/10