Michael Vick or Peyton Manning? Donovan McNabb? The debate rages on... What would you rather have? A player who can control the game by gaining the 10 yards all by himself, the player who sits in the pocket and hits the open reciever everytime, or the player who can do a little bit of both? I know this isn't a player comparison, but it is a widely debated comparison. What is better? The Passing quarterback, or the Scrambling quarterback?
Personally, I would take one who can do both because he is able to do either. I think this would be the choice of lots of people and coaches.
a Vick type player would be best. A scrambler, who can pass. Although alot of times he does not pass well, you do not have to when you have the playmaking ability to gain 40 yards on the ground whenever you have the ball.Scrambling--Vick for me.
Donovan Mcnabb,Because hes used to the pressure and he can scramble if he needs to.Hes also a very good quarter back so i would take him.Peytons good but Mcnabb is probaly a mix between Peyton and Vick.
