Now that we know a lot about the '05 draftees and can better project their future successes, how would you re-do the draft? Take team's needs at the time into considerations, because that's the difference between a draft and a list. I'll start it out - 1. Milwaukee - Chris Paul 2. Atlanta -
Andrew Bynum at 4 BTW a comparasion. Bynum: PPG 12.5 RPG 10.1 APG 1.6 SPG 0.4 BPG 2.1 FG% 0.625 FT% 0.667 3P% 0.000 MPG 29.0 Williams: PPG 16.8 RPG 5.7 APG 1.9 SPG 1.2 BPG 0.4 FG% 0.503 FT% 0.788 3P% 0.333 MPG 36.7 Williams scores slightly more but plays seven more minutes. Bynum has the advantage over Williams in every other category except steals and free throw shooting.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Real @ Dec 27 2007, 02:29 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>Andrew Bynum at 4 BTW a comparasion. Bynum: PPG 12.5 RPG 10.1 APG 1.6 SPG 0.4 BPG 2.1 FG% 0.625 FT% 0.667 3P% 0.000 MPG 29.0 Williams: PPG 16.8 RPG 5.7 APG 1.9 SPG 1.2 BPG 0.4 FG% 0.503 FT% 0.788 3P% 0.333 MPG 36.7 Williams scores slightly more but plays seven more minutes. Bynum has the advantage over Williams in every other category except steals and free throw shooting.</div> Have you watched Marvin, his upside is unreal. A perimeter player shooting 50% is impressive.
I'd take Andrew Bogut over both. 1) Milwaukee - Chris Paul 2) Atlanta - Deron Williams 3) Utah - Marvin Williams (for some reason, even though they had AK47 coming off a great year) 4) New Orleans - Andrew Bynum 5) Charlotte - Danny Granger 6) Portland - Monta Ellis 7) Toronto - Andrew Bogut <div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div><div class='quotemain'>Have you watched Marvin, his upside is unreal. A perimeter player shooting 50% is impressive.</div> He plays a lot at the four and shoots 0.1 three pointers per game. It's not like he's hanging a traditional "perimeter" player. Besides, did you just bring up upside when comparing him to one of the youngest players in the league?
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (o.iatlhawksfan @ Dec 27 2007, 02:33 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Real @ Dec 27 2007, 02:29 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>Andrew Bynum at 4 BTW a comparasion. Bynum: PPG 12.5 RPG 10.1 APG 1.6 SPG 0.4 BPG 2.1 FG% 0.625 FT% 0.667 3P% 0.000 MPG 29.0 Williams: PPG 16.8 RPG 5.7 APG 1.9 SPG 1.2 BPG 0.4 FG% 0.503 FT% 0.788 3P% 0.333 MPG 36.7 Williams scores slightly more but plays seven more minutes. Bynum has the advantage over Williams in every other category except steals and free throw shooting.</div> Have you watched Marvin, his upside is unreal. A perimeter player shooting 50% is impressive. </div> I'm not denying that at all. But Bynum is playing better at this point. Guys like him don't grow on trees.
1. Milwaukee - Chris Paul 2. Atlanta - Deron Williams 3. Utah - Marvin Williams 4. New Orleans - Andrew Bynum 5. Charlotte - Danny Granger 6. Portland - Monta Ellis 7. Toronto - Andrew Bogut 8. New York - Raymond Felton 9. Golden State -
1. Milwaukee - Chris Paul 2. Atlanta - Deron Williams 3. Utah - Marvin Williams 4. New Orleans - Andrew Bynum 5. Charlotte - Danny Granger 6. Portland - Monta Ellis 7. Toronto - Andrew Bogut 8. New York - Raymond Felton 9. Golden State - Sean May (would have opted for a guy like Webster, McCants, or Gracia, but they needed a big) Next on the clock: Los Angeles Lakers
So you'd give them a guy who is found to have horribly chronically bad knees and will be lucky to make it 5 full seasons in the league? Would rather have Maxiell 30x over than May.
Isn't this supposed to be a re-do?? Sean May would go undrafted if we had this draft today. We should do that pick again.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (ghoti @ Dec 27 2007, 02:46 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div><div class='quotemain'>Isn't this supposed to be a re-do“ Sean May would go undrafted if we had this draft today. We should do that pick again.</div> So you're ruling out a recovery? Fair enough. Golden State takes Jason Maxiell.
1. Milwaukee - Chris Paul 2. Atlanta - Deron Williams 3. Utah - Marvin Williams 4. New Orleans - Andrew Bynum 5. Charlotte - Danny Granger 6. Portland - Monta Ellis 7. Toronto - Andrew Bogut 8. New York - Raymond Felton 9. Golden State - Jason Maxiell 10. Los Angeles Lakers - David Lee 11. Orlando -
1. Milwaukee - Chris Paul 2. Atlanta - Deron Williams 3. Utah - Marvin Williams 4. New Orleans - Andrew Bynum 5. Charlotte - Danny Granger 6. Portland - Monta Ellis 7. Toronto - Andrew Bogut 8. New York - Raymond Felton 9. Golden State - Jason Maxiell 10. Los Angeles Lakers - David Lee 11. Orlando - Fran Vasquez j/k 11. Orlando - Martell Webster 12. Los Angeles Clippers -
1. Milwaukee - Chris Paul 2. Atlanta - Deron Williams 3. Utah - Marvin Williams 4. New Orleans - Andrew Bynum 5. Charlotte - Danny Granger 6. Portland - Monta Ellis 7. Toronto - Andrew Bogut 8. New York - Raymond Felton 9. Golden State - Jason Maxiell 10. Los Angeles Lakers - David Lee 11. Orlando - Martell Webster 12. Los Angeles Clippers - Charlie Villaneuva 13. Charlotte Bobcats
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div><div class='quotemain'>So you're ruling out a recovery?</div> I'm saying that no GM would draft May with the current information available, not predicting the future.
1. Milwaukee - Chris Paul 2. Atlanta - Deron Williams 3. Utah - Marvin Williams 4. New Orleans - Andrew Bynum 5. Charlotte - Danny Granger 6. Portland - Monta Ellis 7. Toronto - Andrew Bogut 8. New York - Raymond Felton 9. Golden State - Jason Maxiell 10. Los Angeles Lakers - David Lee 11. Orlando - Martell Webster 12. Los Angeles Clippers - Charlie Villaneuva 13. Charlotte Bobcats - Jarret Jack
