Thanks, beef. But,... <div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (blackadder)</div><div class='quotemain'>Dawk; You have held up admirably defending what appears to be the wrong side of the argument. You could have quite a career writing minority opinions for the Supreme Court.</div> was actually part smack & compliment. After all, I am the Literary sniper.
I just noticed where you were from on your profile....if you get to 1000 next, you can be just like your beloved Eagles, in 2nd....which is really tied for last....like Vince Lombardi should have said, "Win! Or your out of the family"...
actually, if you only count posts that dont contain moronic statements he has a long way to go, about 998 more posts to a 1000. however, i would also like to accept your apology Dawk.
i didnt leave yet, so wait for my shots to come. what should i apologize for? im not hateing on anybody, ur all callin shots at me. i dont see why u 3 are all hatein, im having fun argung with you. so what should i apologize for? my opinions? or for disagreeing with you?
that was a very respectable apology...I humble accept once again....have fun at the shore, you can continue to apologize in a month, when you return, I'll wait....
I, too, accept your sincere, heartfelt apology. It takes a big man to know when he's done something wrong.
However, i think it is time to get his post back on track, i mean lets face it, mcnabb is way to high on the list, he is not a top 50 player much less a top 20 qb.
okay guys back to football!!!! Mcnabb is around top 15 maybe like 13 He is better than Grossman or any QB you've had in awhile
I'm not a huge McNabb fan by any means, but he's at least a top 15 QB. There's not exactly a ton of great, "top-tier", QB's out there right now. Should be interesting to see if Owens helps him complete implode though. It's not like AR has ever had a 1000 yard receiver as long as he's been the head coach.
This thread has been by far the best of the summer. Too funny all around. Some good points some bad points and some overall good humor. keep it up. Still more than a month away from real football talk.
It's gotten crazy... I hadn't even read it until yesterday. The topic didn't interest me so I left it alone. Then I read it yesterday and was blown away... I guess everyone is sick of hearing why Dawk thinks Philly is Superbowl bound. I think it's pretty funny... and I think Philly is in trouble. I guess only time will tell.
Ok, now time to list QB's i consider better than Mcnabb 1)Manning - not much of an argument number wise, and they both have made it the same depth into playoffs(conference title game loss) manning just blows Mcnabb away. 2) Trent Green - his career Qb rating is actually higher than Mcnabb's best season. not much argument here 3) Marc Bulger - took a step back last year but his career qb rating is higher than Mcnabb's best season. Still bulgers last season would have been 3rd best of mcnabbs career, and it was bulger's worst. 4) Matt Hasseback - last two seasons beat any season of Mcnabbs career. 5) Brad Johnson - has 4 seasons superior to any of Mcnabbs and has super bowl ring. 6) Tom Brady, consistently better numbers than mcnabb and has two rings, nuf said. 7) Jon Kitna - his last season was superior to any of mcnabbs career in TDS, Yards, Yards/att, and comp%. He may be getting raw deal not starting over Palmer. Philly should trade for him since he is putting up better numbers than Mcnabb 8) Aaron Brooks - wow his numbers last season are VASTLY superior to Mcnabbs best season. Every year he has started he has had more yards than mcnabb. 9) Daunte Culpepper - Another person with career Qb rating higher than Mcnabbs best season. 10) Brett Farve - Has a long way to go to reach his stature(though i hate him and may kill him) 11) Jake Delhomme - He only has one season starting and it is above par for Mcnabbs career, but his preformance in super bowl(and fact he made it) puts him ahead of Mcnabb in my eyes. 12) Steve Mcnair - CO-MVP i dont think i could make case for Mcnabb being better if i spotted mcnabb some TDS. 13) K. Collins - he had down year last year but the three years before that had better yard numbers than any year of Mcnabbs career. Oh yeah and made it to super bowl. 14) D. Bledsoe - He also had down year but has had 7 seasons with superior yardage numbers to Mcnabb, and Qb rating for careers about same. Also led team to super bowl. best season is better than Mcnabbs best. 15) J. Garcia - Career Qb rating is better than Mcnabbs best season. Even with injury last year garcia had more TDS and better QB rating. 16) J. Plummer - breakout year last year should set all doubters straight. Career is worse than Mcnabbs but he played for a loser all those years seems to be flourishing with a winner. 17) C. Pennington - has not had full season but numbers blow away Mcnabbs, in fact Mcnabb would only be fit to hold his jock if he were on jets. 18) R. Gannon - last season was plagued by injuries, but 4 years before that were all superior to Mcnabbs Best season. plus he made it to super bowl. This does not include - R. Grossman, b.leftwich, C.Palmer, E.Manning, J.P.Losman, P.Rivers, B.Roethlisberger, and D.Henson who all may turn out to be better than Mcnabb. So at best i could put him as the 19th best QB. That is not a "great" QB.
Why would you take Mcnabb over those players? Is it simply a matter of age? that would make sense. Also i forgot, i could make a case warner is a better QB than Mcnabb, better numbers MVP, super bowl win, but i dont think he is quite there now.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Steelerfan_2004)</div><div class='quotemain'>It's gotten crazy... I hadn't even read it until yesterday. The topic didn't interest me so I left it alone. Then I read it yesterday and was blown away... I guess everyone is sick of hearing why Dawk thinks Philly is Superbowl bound. I think it's pretty funny... and I think Philly is in trouble. I guess only time will tell.</div> If I were a defensive co-ordinator, I would simply shut down Terrell and its back to seasons past as there is no other threat @ WR especially since Thrash is back in D.C, I'll go out on a limb and say that once you shut down TO, it'll be easier to stop the Eagles as the running game is significantly weaker w/o Duce.
Not to mention the much weakened pass defense(unless you count two very inexperienced corners better than two multi pro bowlers) It does not look good for the eagles. Not Good at All
i had to come see what uz would say. i knew u 3 were playing, i figured that out a few pages back, and i through some play post in there, but seriously.... .....iam the oracle lol keep poking fun at me, time will tell all of you
