I'm clearly old and out of touch, because I think they're both hideous. My 20-yo daughter: "Hate them both, but the bottom pair is the better of the two" My wife: "Is he trying to match his 80's couch? There is no excuse for any man to wear those shoes."
Probably the most disappointing thing I’ve seen since the Blazers took Meyers Leonard with a lottery pick Please, someone, talk some sense into him
My son (16) says he really likes the loafer, says they look very cool. He is by far the trendiest person in our household.
The fabric looks like a pretty solid match to a couch my grandparents had when I was growing up. Just needs the plastic cover.
Those shoes give very Robert Graham vibes. https://www.robertgraham.us/collections/shoes If between the two, the sneakers. They are very inappropriate for any kind of dress shoes to look like that.