Isn't this the same injury that Ilgauskas had? Didn't he too have difficulty coming back from it? It took some time, and some experts agreed that his career was over but look at him now. He's a 7 footer and made a comeback. Granted, Hill has had a much tougher go at it but still deserves one last chance before throwing in the towel. Why do people have to insist that it's going to be one way or the other? Give him a break (not his ankle) and let him try once more. He's smart, and will give up it doesn't work. If it does, watch out... he's a smart player, and there aren't too many of those in the game.