Except for the drafting part (which would be a blast for the 2 coaches, i know how much i love drafting haha)... that is a good idea... but then the league should put some rules like: players that obviously don't deserve it can't be voted in... or if a player is injured, he can't be voted in during the time he's out
It's an interesting idea, but I don't think it would draw any interest. What they really need to do is revamp the slam dunk contest. This was the event that got everyone hyped about the All Star weekend.
One thing they should do with the ASG is that they should play it for a win. At the moment it's just dunking and lay-ups until the last minute.
The last good All-Star game was in 2001. I'm up for anything to make what is now utter shit exciting again.