I can only keep 2 of these three... which ones would you keep? Cadillac Williams - Round 5 Willis McGahee - Round 9 Chester Taylor - Round 17 The round indicated is which round I have to give up in this season's draft to keep this player. Thoughts?
At first thought I'd say Taylor but then if you consider injuries and young QB's I would keep him. Cadilac might wearout again but as good as I think McGahee is with Losman there he'll have a tough time. To tough for me to call cause it may be luck of the draw between those 3
I'd keep both Williams and McGahee. The rounds you have them in are good rounds and both are legit fantasy starters. Williams had a solid year last year and with an improved line he should get better. McGahee ran for 1300 yards last year and is very overlooked.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (porky88)</div><div class='quotemain'>I'd keep both Williams and McGahee. The rounds you have them in are good rounds and both are legit fantasy starters. Williams had a solid year last year and with an improved line he should get better. McGahee ran for 1300 yards last year and is very overlooked.</div> AS long as he can start finding the endzone last year he only got 5 td's but this year he seems less cocky and more focused.
Keep williams and mcgahee.. it will cost a 5th and 9th both would go before those rounds anyways.. Both are legit starters in Fantasy Football they aren't awsome well they can be.. but u have 4 rounds to make the RB position better with someone else I think mcgahee will have another Good season.. if Losman can get his crap together and cadillac will only get better... so i would keep them both..
Taylor will get a chance to be "the guy" this year and could work out great for you. And all for the 17th rounder makes him a can't lose chance that I think you should take. Low risk/high reward. Flip a coin for which one of the other 2 to keep.
I have my doubts about Chester Taylor, I don't know if he can carry for the Vikings all season, they do have some nice depth behind him to keep him fresh though. Cadillac is a must, I myself would probably take Willis over Chester but hey Im also the guy that traded Joey Galloway and Thomas Jones away for we'll just say lesser players that season lol.
i think you go with the sure things of Williams and McGahee. Taylor u never know about but with those two you know ur getting two young good up and coming RBs
drop taylor, he is basically a 50-50 shot at being succesful or not while the ohter two you know will give you 1000 and 6-10 td's easy.
