I'd take T-Mac over Kobe by a little. I see them as basically having the same skill, it's just Kobe's attitude that makes him less desirable than T-Mac. He is a drama queen and a ballhog. If he took less shots and dominated the ball less I would take him over T-Mac. However, Kobe is a better shooter I think. I forget which game it was, but this year I saw Kobe hit a shot clock beating left handed baseline three with a hand in his face. I don't think T-Mac or anyone else in the league could hit that shot.