First off, hello? Sup.
The OP is not crazy.
Can we win a title with Dame as our best player?
Can any team win a title with Dame a their best player? The answer is no. Kyrie Irving, who is better, and way more skilled than Dame proved he cannot carry a team as the best player, so Dame has zero chance of doing that especially in the West.
I agree with the OP. I want to do right by Dame. However, I also want to make a business decision.
Hypothetically, what can we get for Dame?
Were can we send him?
Does he want to do what he once bashed and team up with superteams?
What can contenders offer a rebuilding franchise?
I am 100% all in on a rebuild, but that is just the opinion of one man. I think we can get a pretty haul for Dame and CJ. We don't have a true superstar, that other superstars want to play with. That is how the league is build now. You either trust the process like Philly and Golden State, or build super-teams like Brooklyn and LA. The former is more feasible imo, because people are not lining up to play with Dame like they are LeBron, Kyrie, or Curry. We are also not bad enough to get #1 draft picks.
Olshey found Dame and CJ, I trust him in a full rebuild.